• MSN
  • Hotmail
  • More
    • Autos
    • My MSN
    • Video
    • Careers & Jobs
    • Personals
    • Weather
    • Delish
    • Quotes
    • White Pages
    • Games
    • Real Estate
    • Wonderwall
    • Horoscopes
    • Shopping
    • Yellow Pages
    • Local Edition
    • Traffic
    • Feedback
    • Maps & Directions
    • Travel
    • Full MSN Index
  • Bing
  • NBCNews.com
  • TODAY
  • Nightly News
  • Rock Center
  • Meet the Press
  • Dateline
  • msnbc
  • Breaking News
  • Newsvine
  • Home
  • US
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Travel
  • Local
  • Weather
Advertise | AdChoices
  • Recommended: Report: Chinese army tied to widespread US hacking
  • Recommended: Chinese official booted after account of lurid affair emerges
  • Recommended: In debt or jobless, many Italians choose suicide
  • Recommended: Carnival-like atmosphere in Myanmar ahead of election

World Blog provides a dynamic look at world events and trends from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world.

  • ↓ About this blog
  • ↓ Archives
    • Icons Email E-mail updates
    • Icons Twitter Follow on Twitter
    • Icons Feed Subscribe to RSS
  • 10
    May
    2012
    12:42pm, EDT

    City divided by disgraced Communist leader's legacy

    The murder of an English business man and corruption scandal, involving one of the China's most powerful men, has gripped the country. NBC's Ian Williams reports.

    By Ed Flanagan, NBC News

    CHONGQING, China – Everywhere you go in Chongqing, you can see traces of the complicated legacy of Bo Xilai, the former Communist party chief who ran this municipality of 30 million people until scandal derailed him. 

    At one time destined for a top post in China’s highest echelon of power, the standing committee of the politburo of the Communist Party, Bo aggressively poured money into this municipality in pursuit of his populist agenda.

    To drive through the windy roads that snake around this hilly metropolis is to see a city in constant transformation. Towers of low-income housing complexes dot the skyline. These social housing projects were meant to address a major national issue: the lack of affordable housing, and provided homes that cost just a few hundred dollars a year to rent. And Bo had gingko trees, said to be one of his favorites, planted across the city.

    But these city improvements came at a cost: His heavy investment in capital construction projects forced the city to borrow so much money to pay for it that Chongqing owes $20 billion to the China Development Bank, according to a news report on Wednesday. The tree planting saddled the city with a $1.5 billion bill just for 2010 alone.  

    The improvements weren’t the only controversial aspect of Bo’s reign over this important gateway city to the western half of China, and since his demise his critics have stepped out of the shadows to talk about the darker side of life in what had become the former leader’s personal fiefdom.


    Told a Bo joke, got a year in a labor camp

    In Chongqing, NBC News spoke with Fang Hong, a 51-year-old former forestry officer who made news earlier this week when he filed an appeal with a local court seeking compensation for what he alleged was an unfair sentence he served at a labor camp.

    According to Fang, he was imprisoned for posting a two-line joke about Bo on his microblog that quickly went viral. Soon after, Fang said he was dragged in by police for questioning and later brought before a police tribunal where he was sentenced for “fabricating facts and disturbing public order.” 

    Fang served his sentence at a labor camp where he said he was forced to assemble thousands of Christmas ornaments for export for one year.

    Released earlier this year, Fang was emboldened by the criticism that has shrouded Bo following his high-profile falling out with his vice-mayor and former police chief, Wang Lijun, who famously sought refuge at the American embassy in Chengdu. That move by Wang sparked an international political scandal that now includes a murder mystery. Bo’s wife, Gu Kailai, is a murder suspect in the death of British businessman Neil Heywood; Bo has been officially disowned by the ruling Communist Party and has disappeared from public view.

    Ed Flanagan / NBC News

    A crowd gathers around Fang Hong in Chongqing to hear his story on Tuesday.

    Boisterous debate on Bo
    Fang agreed to do an interview with NBC News on an outside promenade with commanding views of Chongqing’s skyline and the mighty Yangtze River below. Fang spoke confidently, eager to tell his story about the deprivations he faced while interned at the labor camp.

    Between the presence of a foreign camera crew and his loud denouncements of Bo Xilai, Fang quickly drew a crowd of onlookers.

    The first indication that things were going to get contentious with the crowd was when one short, middle-aged man standing next to the camera started muttering under his breath as he listened to Fang. 

    Taking jagged drags from his cigarette and nervously flicking ash between puffs, the man’s voice rose incrementally to voice his protestations of Fang’s opinion about Bo. Those near to the man shushed him as they strained to hear what Fang was saying, but after one particular statement, the man clearly had enough.

    “That’s bull---! Bo Xilai has done so much for Chongqing!” bellowed the man as he waved his cigarette at Fang.

    The crowd erupted into a loud, boisterous debate on Bo, prompting NBC News correspondent Ian Williams to wrap up the interview so that Fang could quickly leave with his lawyers.

    But before he left, Fang feistily told the man what he thought of his opinion, triggering a shouting match. One of Fang’s lawyers and some of the crowd had to separate the pair.

    David Lom / NBC News

    Angry pro-Bo Xilai supporter voices his opinion to the crowd in Chongqing.

    ‘Since Bo Xilai took power I feel more secure'
    Not everyone had negative feelings about the disgraced former party chief.

     One older woman in the crowd said:, “Before, I was worried to wear earrings because I was worried I’d get robbed, but since Bo Xilai I feel more secure seeing more police on the streets.”

    Finally, a line of security guards rolled up and broke up the crowd. The guards were not forceful and they exchanged a few knowing nods with the throng of people who were loudly voicing their support for Bo.

    Bo’s fall has clearly given his critics the opportunity they’ve long desired to voice their criticisms of him.

    However, despite the accusations that paint Bo’s Chongqing was something akin to a modern-day Tammany Hall, the populism and perhaps most importantly, the pride he instilled in this mega-city suggest his popular legacy may last far longer than Communist Party officials would like.

    As one driver told us, “Yeah, Bo might have been corrupt, but at least he did something for us – which is more than those corrupt officials who do nothing at all.”   

    NBC News’ Bo Gu contributed to this report.


    Follow @msnbc_world

    10 comments

    I guess the same could be said about Hitler; but I think most people in the world agree that he was a piece of crap. All politicians are corrupt, some are just way worse than others.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, politics, scandal, featured, chongqing, bo-xilai, ed-flanagan
  • 17
    Apr
    2012
    3:59pm, EDT

    Scandal sends China's netizens into a feeding frenzy

    Jason Lee / Reuters

    China's Chongqing Municipality Communist Party Secretary Bo Xilai waves a Chinese national flag during an event in Chongqing municipality in this June 2011 file photo.

    By Bo Gu, NBC News

    BEIJING – It’s the biggest news in China in a long time – and China’s netizens are finding ways to get around censors to gossip and get the latest online rumors.

    The scandal, which has spread to the New York Times front page and other Western news outlets, is centered on Bo Xilai, the former Communist Party secretary of Chongqing, China’s biggest municipality with 30 million residents, and his wife, Gu Kailai, who is a murder suspect in the death of British businessman Neil Heywood.

    Before the bombshell announcement from China’s official news agency, Bo had been considered one of the top contenders for the country’s highest echelon of power, the standing committee of the politburo of the Communist Party, in the upcoming power reshuffle this fall.
     
    No further official information has been released since last Tuesday’s news, but it still seems as if China’s entire population of 1.3 billion people is talking about the scandal. And despite the government’s best efforts to squelch online chatter, the country’s savvy computer fans have come up with novel ways to circumvent Beijing’s watchdogs.  


    Foreign 'rumors'
    Foreign media have continued to feed the voracious appetite for more juicy details from Chinese netizens.

    Kyodo / Reuters

    China's former Chongqing Municipality Communist Party Secretary Bo Xilai and his wife Gu Kailai in a January 2007 file photo.

    Many in China have made use of VPNs (virtual private networks) to circumvent the Great Firewall to access these Western reports, as well as overseas Chinese websites like Boxun, or Hong Kong and Taiwanese media reports. 

    Every time a new article comes out, it’s instantly translated into Chinese and posted on Weibo, China’s most popular Twitter-like service, followed by tons of comments and re-tweets.

    The foreign reports have delved into everything about Gu Kailai, Bo’s wife, from her business dealings to her friends and close personal relationship with Heywood.

    The extravagant lifestyle of Bo Guagua, Bo Xilai and Gu’s only son, has also come under the spotlight in foreign news reports – from his hard-partying ways at expensive private schools such as, Harrow, Oxford and Harvard, to his penchant for fast cars.   

    And on Tuesday Reuters added a new wrinkle to the story with a report that Bo initially agreed to a police probe of his wife's role in the murder before abruptly reversing course and demoting his police chief, which eventually led to the downfall of both men.

    The government has applied every method possible to silence not just the local press, but the public passing along tidbits from the foreign reports.

    Posts regarding the Bo scandal, defined by the official media as “rumors,” are usually deleted quickly after they show up online. Major web portals have been ordered to intensify their monitoring of allegedly scurrilous reports. And government mouthpieces like CCTV and Xinhua have appealed to the public to stop spreading rumors.

    Chinese authorities do not issue empty threats – at least six people were recently arrested for posting gossip about a rumored military coup in Beijing.

    Getting around the Great Firewall
    But cracking down on gossip is an enormous project in China. The country’s sophisticated netizens – who now number up to an estimated 500 million – pass along rumors using puns, hints and words with different Chinese characters but similar pronunciation to key words.

    For instance, the word “Bo,” which also means “thin” in Chinese, has been replaced by the term “not thick.” Many posts have called Bo “the not thick governor” in order to slide past censors.  

    Meanwhile, some witty netizens have referred to the city of Chongqing as “tomato,” because tomato is pronounced “Xi Hong Shi” in Chinese, which sounds the same as “Western Red City.” That seemingly cryptic reference is to the “red revolutionary song” campaign initiated by Bo when he was governing Chongqing. As the son of a major leader of China’s Communist Revolution, Bo was also famous for promoting a campaign to revive Cultural Revolution-era “red culture.”

    “This is the most remarkable event [in China] ever since 1976, when the Gang of Four was arrested,” said Yao Bo, a China-based Internet observer and blogger, in a phone interview with NBC News. He was referring to when the leaders of China’s disastrous Cultural Revolution were publicly purged from the Communist Party a month after Chairman Mao’s death – marking the end of one of China’s most turbulent political eras.

    “When people used to talk about politics on forums or bulletins before, it was censored much more easily, since such discussion always had a topic. Weibo is like a virus, it can share information much faster and becomes uncontrollable,” Yao said.

    ‘We Firmly Support the Central Party’
    The government has tried to introduce a counter-campaign of sorts by ordering all major newspapers and TV news channels to pledge their loyalty to the Communist Party. Within a few days after Bo’s scandal was exposed, a variety of publications had editorials with the same headline: “We Firmly Support the Central Party.”
     
    Some leftist websites that openly supported a return to a Maoist-like regime have been mysteriously shut down in recent days – another signal suggesting its best time to stick to the party line. None of them has publicly stated that they are following an official order, but they all went into “maintenance-mode” simultaneously.
     
    Over the last few days less gossip devoted to the Bo scandal has appeared online, which Yao attributed to both censorship and the political nature of the scandal. 

    “What Bo did was to pull China in an extreme direction when nobody knew where it was going. The leftists say ‘it’s a red trial,’ the rightists say ‘it’s a disaster.’ Now he’s down, people have nothing to argue about. This is a signal sent by the highest leaders that they do not wish to go back to China’s past.”
     
    “This has made netizens realize one thing: rumor is another name for truth,” said Yao.

    More world news from msnbc.com and NBC News:

    Afghan schoolgirls poisoned in anti-education attack

    Norway mass killer Anders Breivik: I 'would do it all again'

    Japanese island man lives as naked hermit

    Tunisia still wants sun lovers, new Islamist government says

    Sources: Briton killed after threat to expose Chinese leader's wife

    US prepares for last major Afghanistan offensive

     

    Follow us on Twitter: @msnbc_world

    36 comments

    The government has applied every method possible to silence not just the local press, but the public passing along tidbits from the foreign reports.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, scandal, communist-party, featured, bo-xilai, bo-gu, gu-kailai

Browse

  • featured,
  • egypt,
  • china,
  • afghanistan,
  • libya,
  • world-news,
  • pakistan,
  • israel,
  • hosni-mubarak,
  • japan,
  • middle-east,
  • tsunami,
  • ed-flanagan,
  • richard-engel,
  • ian-williams,
  • japan-earthquake,
  • 2010,
  • adrienne-mong,
  • jim-maceda,
  • bo-gu,
  • charlene-gubash,
  • mubarak,
  • world-cup,
  • protests,
  • after-the-wave,
  • cairo,
  • miranda-leitsinger,
  • germany,
  • italy,
  • north-korea,
  • iran,
  • gadhafi,
  • thailand,
  • russia,
  • london,
  • u-s,
  • claudio-lavanga,
  • palestinians,
  • paul-goldman,
  • ayman-mohyeldin,
  • somalia,
  • britain,
  • syria,
  • protest,
  • andy-eckardt
Also
Advertise | AdChoices

World Blog

NBC News World Blog provides a dynamic look at world events and trends – both big and small – from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries – from text to video – explore the latest news events and how they are shaping our world. Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog!

Follow us

Ed Flanagan

is a Beijing-based producer for NBC News. In China since 2005, he has been a part of the team's China as well as regional news coverage.

Ed Flanagan Blogroll

  • Michael Pettis
  • James Fallows
  • China Law Blog
  • Silicon Hutong
  • Sinica Podcasts
  • China Digital Times
  • The China Beat
  • China Geeks
  • NBC World Blog
  • China Hush

Bo Gu

Associate Producer at Beijing Bureau, NBC News

Bo Gu Blogroll

  • Ministry of Toufu
  • China Expat

Archives

  • 2013
    • March (1)
    • February (1)
    • January (2)
  • 2012
    • December (2)
    • November (1)
    • September (1)
    • August (1)
    • July (3)
    • May (6)
    • April (28)
    • March (40)
    • February (33)
    • January (44)
  • 2011
    • December (41)
    • November (51)
    • October (37)
    • September (39)
    • August (46)
    • July (35)
    • June (33)
    • May (31)
    • April (16)
    • March (46)
    • February (159)
    • January (42)
  • 2010
    • December (16)
    • November (20)
    • October (19)
    • September (23)
    • August (33)
    • July (28)
    • June (36)
    • May (26)
    • April (37)
    • March (30)
    • February (44)
    • January (29)
  • 2009
    • December (21)
    • November (19)
    • October (24)
    • September (23)
    • August (15)
    • July (27)
    • June (32)
    • May (24)
    • April (30)
    • March (24)
    • February (26)
    • January (35)
  • 2008
    • December (25)
    • November (31)
    • October (27)
    • September (17)
    • August (22)
    • July (21)
    • June (29)
    • May (30)
    • April (27)
    • March (26)
    • February (27)
    • January (28)
  • 2007
    • December (18)
    • November (28)
    • October (25)
    • September (32)
    • August (32)
    • July (25)
    • June (32)
    • May (24)
    • April (21)
    • March (29)
    • February (21)
    • January (28)

Most Commented

    Other blogs

    • Daily Nightly
    • The Maddow Blog
    • The Last Word
    • Hardblogger
    • First Read
    • World Blog
    • Field Notes
    • Inside Dateline
    • Behind the Wall
    • The Ed Show
    • Morning Joe
    • Daily Rundown

    NBCNews.com top stories

    3147,10
    © 2013 NBCNews.com
    • World news on NBCNews.com
    • About us
    • Contact
    • Help
    • Site map
    • Careers
    • Closed captioning
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy policy
    • Advertise