Jump to January 2011 archive page: 1 2
  • Naked Emperor: One sex scandal too many for Berlusconi?

    STRINGER/ITALY / Reuters

    Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi reacts during a news conference at Chigi Palace in Rome on Sept.23, 2010.

    By NBC News’ Claudio Lavanga

    Did you hear the one about Silvio and the Moroccan belly dancer?

    Unfortunately, for the 74-year-old Italian leader, most of Italy has – and the people are not pleased.

    A confidential new document containing lurid details about the investigation into the nature of Silvio Berlusconi’s relationship with Karima El Mahroug, an under-aged Moroccan belly dancer nicknamed “Ruby the Heart-Stealer,” could be the final straw for the seemingly indestructible Italian leader.

    The 389-page investigation, leaked on the Web this week, contains wire taps of phone conversations full of candid details about backdoor dealings and wild parties that suggest the prime minister has lived a life of unconstrained debauchery aided by an entourage of teenage showgirls, television presenters and talent-scouts.

    And it has led to a criminal investigation.

    Prosecutors allege that Berlusconi paid for sex with the underage teen and then lied to authorities in order to cover it up.

    The lengthy dossier was presented to Italy’s parliament on Monday in order to get special permission to search some of Berlusconi’s properties. Parliament said it will take at least a week to digest all of the information and issue a decision.

    Some of the salacious quotes from the leaked wire tap include:

    • “There were orgies in there – not with drugs, as far as I know. But they were all drinking, half undressed. Berlusconi started singing and telling jokes. Three [men] and 28 girls. By the end . . . the girls had no bras on and were wearing only those tight knickers.”
    - Carlo Ferrigno, a former head of a police intelligence service and anti-racketeering commissioner

    • “It’s unbelievable. You don’t know. All of them call him ‘love’ or ‘darling.’ You can’t begin to imagine what goes on there. The papers don’t tell the half of it, even when they’re massacring him.”
    -  An unnamed party guest

    Antonio Calanni / AP

    Karima El Mahroug, an under-aged Moroccan belly dancer nicknamed “Ruby the Heart-Stealer,” whose encounters with Italy's Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi are at the base of a prostitution probe which is rocking Italian politics, is interviewed for a TV show in Milan, Italy, on Wednesday.

    •  “[Berlusconi] called me and said, ‘Ruby, I’ll give you whatever amount you want. I’ll pay you. I’ll cover you in gold, but the important thing is to keep everything under wraps. Don’t say a thing to anyone.’”
    - Karima El Mahroug, aka “Ruby the Heart Stealer,” to former boyfriend Sergio Corsaro on Oct. 7, 2010

    • “I told Silvio I wanted 5 million euros for all this. He said that I should just keep making things up and pretend I’m mad – but not reveal anything and stay quiet.”
    - El Mahroug to a friend

    • “You either do everything or you take a taxi and leave. It’s a real whorehouse there. Berlusconi is touching all the girls’ bottoms. It’s worse than the papers say.”
    -  Unidentified girl who went to party, to a friend

    •  “If you do these things in your own bedroom, fine. But in front of everyone else? I ask how [he] can go to work the next day?”
    - Unidentified girl who went to party to a friend

    •  “I thought he’d put on weight; he looked uglier. Last year, [Berlusconi] was looking fitter; now he’s looking over the hill. And he’s ugly with it. He’s just got to cough up. Let’s hope he’s more generous.”
    - Showgirl Imma De Vivo, to her twin sister, Eleonora, on Sept. 25, 2010

    • “I’ve been going to the prime minister’s house since I was 16 years old, but I have always denied everything to protect him.”
    El Mahroug to a friend on Oct. 26, 2010

    • “She [El Mahroug] said she was very friendly with the Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi. She often went to his house for dinner, to sing, dance, and she had sex with him, for which he gave her lots of money.”
    - El Mahroug's roommate, Caterina Pasquina, to investigators

    ‘The Heart-stealer’
    It all started with a minor incident that quickly snowballed into one of Italy’s biggest political scandal: In May of last year, El Mahroug, a runaway teenager, was arrested on suspicion of theft in the northern city of Milan.

    While the police looked into the report that she stole thousands of euros and expensive watches from an Italian woman at a beauty parlour she briefly worked for, they thought they were dealing with a minor who got herself in trouble after running away from her family in Sicily. But even before they managed to contact her parents, they received a call from the most unlikely of guardian: Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi.

    ALESSANDRO GAROFALO / Reuters

    Nicole Minetti smiles during a meeting at the Lombardy regional headquarters in Milan on Jan. 18.

    From Paris, he said that she was the niece of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak and asked for her immediate release in order to avoid a diplomatic incident. The police obeyed without asking questions, and handed the girl over to another shady character in Berlusconi’s entourage: Nicole Minetti, a former showgirl and dental hygienist who treated Berlusconi’s injuries after he was attacked with a marble statue in 2009, and who was elected in the regional elections for his People of Freedom’s Party months later.

    When it became clear that El Mahroug wasn’t related to the Egyptian president, and in fact wasn’t Egyptian at all, she was a 17-year-old Moroccan, investigators asked: Why would the prime minister go to such lengths, including lying to the police, to ensure the release of an unrelated teenager?

    Cash, diamonds and Bunga-Bunga 
    Back in September 2009, El Mahroug wasn’t a heart stealer, but was dreaming of becoming one.

    She hit the catwalk at a local beauty contest in a small town in Sicily hoping her Mediterranean beauty would propel her into the world of show business, but only managed to win a minor ribbon.

    However, one of the judges at the contest was said to be 80-year-old Emilio Fede, a trusted friend of Berlusconi and a journalist who makes no secret of his staunch support for the prime minister during his newscasts on Italy’s Channel 4.

    According to El Mahroug’s testimony, she met Fede through Lele Mora, a show business talent-scout and close aide of Berlusconi, and was later invited to Arcore, Berlusconi’s private residence on the outskirts of Milan.

    At first, she told investigators, she was invited for dinner and showered with expensive presents, such as 7,000 euros (about $9,400) and a diamond necklace. During one of her dinners at Berlusconi’s residence, she claims to have attended one of his after-parties, the infamous “bunga-bunga,” an erotic ritual that she says Berlusconi learnt from his friend Muammar Gaddafi, the Libyan leader.

    While El Mahroug has always maintained that she never had sex with the prime minister, she told magistrates that the bunga-bunga parties were hardcore orgies with tens of skimpily-dressed or naked aspiring showgirls flirting with the prime minister, who later would choose whom to have sex with.

    Nevertheless, the main question investigators are looking into is: Was the  prime minister aware that El Mahroug was underage?

    From BLTWY: How to party like Silvio Berlusconi

    ‘I just wanted to help’ 
    When confronted about the allegations, Berlusconi initially downplayed the incident by claiming he took pity on the teenager and simply wanted to help her out. But magistrates following the case believe that his charitable work went beyond giving El Mahroug another shot at freedom and showering her with expensive presents.

    Information about her movements, obtained by investigators who monitored her mobile phone, show that El Mahroug downplayed the extent of her relationship with the prime minister.

    Instead of attending only a few parties, as El Mahroug claimed, the data revealed she spent whole weekends in Berlusconi’s private residence without leaving the premises, raising questions over the real nature of their relationship.

    In Italy, paying for sex with an under-aged woman is a crime punishable with a maximum sentence of three years in prison.  

    Is Berlusconi a projection of the average Italian?
    When El Mahroug's scandal made headlines at the end of last year, it was easy to believe the prime minister would sail through the latest crisis in his typical defiant fashion. After all, it wasn’t the first time he was accused of having had sex with a prostitute, nor was it the first time his relationship with teenagers was called into question.

    In 2009, an escort named Patrizia D'Addario claimed to have slept with Berlusconi at his Rome residence and released secret recordings of their conversations, which seemed to support her claim.

    The same year, his wife filed for divorce saying she could no longer be with a man who “consorts with minors” after it emerged he attended the 18th birthday party of an aspiring model, Noemi Letizia. Scores of other women, some claiming to be prostitutes, have since come forward claiming to have attended Berlusconi’s parties.

    And yet Italians don’t seem to mind. Most of his supporters have accepted his theory that he is the victim of a plot by “communist magistrates” who are out to get him.

    But his apparent invincibility, according to one of sociologist Franco Ferrarotti, comes from the fact he is the projection of what most Italians would like to be.

    “They see in him a lot of what they are,” Ferrarotti told msnbc.com. “Italians are hypocrites by nature: In public, they condemn his action. But in the privacy of their own bedroom, they are very, very liberal.”

    Can the invincible Berlusconi survive this one?
    Everyone is equal before the law.  But is Berlusconi “more equal” than others?

    The investigation was announced just hours after Italy’s Constitutional Court ruled as unlawful parts of an immunity law that would have prevented Berlusconi from going on trial.

    Faced with mounting pressure and the prospect of prosecution, Berlusconi has defended himself in typical fashion: by appearing on television.

    As a media mogul, Berlusconi is credited with both building his wealth and his political fortunes on the exploitation of his three commercial television channels. So it didn’t come to anyone’s surprise when once again he professed his innocence to Italians by broadcasting a video message.

    "There's nothing I should be ashamed of,” he said in the pre-recorded message. “I would like to go on trial immediately, but with impartial judges, not with prosecutors who want to use this case as a means of political fight."

    The lower house of parliament now has one month to consider the request to search Berlusconi’s premises to find evidence against him.

    But one thing is certain: Despite the fact he is the man who introduced variety shows, quiz games and drama serials to Italian audiences, no soap opera can match the twist and turns of his life. 

  • Analysis: U.S. 'playing catch-up' in battle against lone-wolf terrorists

    By Andy Hayman, NBC News counterterrorism analyst

    LONDON - The pressure on the security and intelligence services is unrelenting. There hardly seems to be a month that goes by without a terrorist alert or an actual attack.

    Nearly a decade on from the 9/11 atrocities, an attack by extremists remains one of the biggest threats to the safety of citizens in both the United States and United Kingdom.

    However, during the early part of this decade, the U.S. appeared immune to a particularly dangerous form of terrorism well-known to authorities in the U.K. — home-grown, "lone-wolf" attackers.

    Last year, that started to change.

    In May, Faisal Shahzad, a Pakistani-born U.S. citizen, tried to detonate a car bomb near New York's Times Square. In November — at the lighting of a community Christmas Tree in Portland, Ore. — Mohamed Osman Mohamud allegedly attempted to detonate a car bomb.

    The lone-wolf terrorist is undoubtedly more challenging to detect and stop than the typical cell of six to 10 people.

    Undercover operatives
    With those kinds of numbers, there is a much greater chance that the cell's internal security will break down and a leak will occur, giving the authorities an opportunity to infiltrate the cell with undercover operatives or set up surveillance.

    A lone attacker only has to look after themselves and ensure they talk to no one and keep under the radar of friends and the authorities.

    Preventative techniques become more difficult to deploy which actually means the lone operator can present the greater danger to public safety than an organized cell of several people.

    Home-grown Islamist terrorists struck in the U.K. in dramatic fashion five years ago when 52 people were killed in the so-called 7/7 attack on London's transport system.

    The chilling sound of suicide bomber Mohammad Siddique Khan reciting his martyrdom video in a broad regional accent brought home to all the British authorities that, right under their noses, was a new breed of Islamist: English people radicalized within their own communities to the point where they were willing to kill.

    The revelation prompted the U.K. to re-think what was needed to deal with this combined threat from the home-grown and international terrorist.

    A slight twist on the homegrown, lone-wolf bomber was the attack in December by Taimour Abdulwahab al-Abdaly. Although a Swedish citizen he had permanent resident status in the U.K. It is believed he became radicalized while in the U.K. and left his family home in Luton, England, to mount an attack in Stockholm, Sweden.

    Focus diverted?
    The worrying aspect is that there do not appear to be tangible lessons which can be shared with the U.S., which it could be argued is playing catch-up on how to deal with the threat of the home-grown bomber.

    There is always the danger that trying to deal with the threat at home could divert focus away from plots being hatched overseas, and vice versa.

    And we know that providing additional resources is not necessarily the answer and that focusing on community programs to prevent radicalization has only limited success.

    Despite nearly five years of effort and £100 million ($160 million) of investment into counter-radicalization programs, terrorist cells are still emerging.

    In December, nine terror suspects were charged with acts preparatory to the commission of acts of terrorism after they allegedly plotted to mount attacks on iconic London locations during the holiday period.

    Such activities, if proved, raise questions about the merits of the British preventative program.

    It might sound bleak, but it may simply be a case of conceding defeat within the preventative agenda and preserving scant resources to keep one step ahead of the terrorist with greater intelligence coverage and proactive security operations.

    It is still not clear just how well prepared Britain and America are to deal with these types of attacks.

    Whether the U.S. can find a better solution than the U.K.'s strategy to prevent the radicalization of its citizens alongside policing operations, remains to be seen.

    Andy Hayman is a former assistant commissioner with London's Metropolitan Police. In that role, he was the highest-ranking police officer responsible for counterterrorism in the U.K.

  • Tunisia leaves Arab leaders wondering: Should I pack a bag?

    By Richard Engel, NBC News Chief Foreign Correspondent
     
    TUNIS, Tunisia – The Arab world has been changed by the uprising in Tunisia, but don’t expect to see the region’s government officials booking bulk rates on charter planes to Saudi Arabia any time soon. The changes that Tunisia’s popular revolt will bring to the Middle East will be slow, but profound, according to Middle East experts.
     
    But what do they know? Middle East experts didn’t predict a month ago that Tunisia’s autocratic regime would fall like a cardiac case, so take their comments with a shaker of salt. 
     
    Why did Tunis fall you ask again? Tunisia was an incongruous blend of poor people living in a rich country; educated people living in a boorish, outdated police state.

    Thibault Camus / AP

    Protestor holds a Tunisian flag as he shouts slogans during a demonstration against the party of deposed President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, in the center of Tunis, Wednesday.

    Under the so-black-it’s-almost-purple-haired 74-year-old President Zine el-Abideen Ben Ali, currently cooling his heels in exile in Saudi Arabia, Tunisia’s economy was strong. But Tunisians lost their tolerance for old-fashioned repression and dictators’ timeworn favorites, like censorship, police intimidation and one-party rule. 

    To the Tunisian kids, it felt oh so Stalin-like, so passé. Most Tunisians these days are on Facebook, that Web page some of you might have used that seems to want to take credit for every revolt on the planet, including the ones claimed by Twitter. Before Facebook and Twitter, students and other agitators with low boiling points organized revolts by talking. The tongue was the mighty weapon when a rallying cry was actually cried, but we didn’t call them Tongue Revolutions.
     
    When not coming up with excuses for failing to predict the ouster of Tunisia’s president, most Middle East experts point to Egypt’s leaders as the next candidates to earn frequent flier miles on Saudi Arabian Airlines.
     
    Like in Tunisia, Egypt’s population is rapidly losing interest in being told what to do.  But President Hosni Mubarak, who appears to share a colorist with Ben Ali, knows how to contain a revolt. Egypt has been in a state of emergency since 1981. Its security services are accused of being both brutal and efficient, with brutal playing the starring role. It seems unlikely that a few thousand protesters would send the Egyptian government shopping for suitcases.
     
    The Tunisia effect could be a slow burn. Mubarak has made it as clear as Nile water (which is not that clear, yet clear enough) that he wants his son Gamal to follow him as president. Will that still be possible? 

    The Egyptian people might not have accepted Gamal as the political waters stood a month ago.  Now that Ben Ali has left for his off-season pilgrimage to Saudi Arabia, Egyptians’ tolerance for events that might have seemed inevitable could be lower. Even renowned fatalists like Egyptians might decide to decide their own futures.  (Note to readers based on this journalist’s experiences living in Egypt: It is best to avoid riding in taxis in places where people believe they do not control their own destinies. Fatalism may bring inner peace, but it is not good for defensive driving.)
     
    Which other countries in the Middle East have educated, fed-up people, along with poverty, repressive regimes and high corruption you ask again? The list is long. Which will fall next, if any? 

    Middle East experts will undoubtedly spend great amounts of time and limited brainpower guessing the wrong ones, not that that matters much. Facebook will take credit for the revolutions in any case.
     

  • Irish abuse victim: New letter proves Vatican cover-up

    By NBC News’ Claudio Lavanga

    A 1997 letter from a Vatican official advising Irish bishops not to report suspected child abuse cases to the police has sent shockwaves across the Catholic world.

    To child abuse victims, it’s the “smoking gun” that proves what they have claimed all along: that the Vatican actively tried to prevent criminal investigations against sexually abusive priests by instructing bishops not to report them to the police.

    But to the Vatican, it’s just another example of how past mistakes in handling abuse cases have since been corrected.

    Damaging evidence
    The letter, published by the Irish broadcaster RTE on Monday, revealed that Archbishop Luciano Storero, then the Vatican’s apostolic nuncio to Ireland (the equivalent of a Vatican ambassador), told Irish bishops that the Vatican had doubts about their “mandatory reporting” policy for suspected abusers to civil authorities.

    The new policy had been introduced by Irish bishops following revelations in the mid-1990s of the abuse of dozens of children. The scandal was so big at the time that it brought down the entire Irish government

    The Vatican letter instructed bishops that abuse allegations and punishments were to be handled within the church through canon law. It warned that bishops who tried to pursue charges outside of canon law could have their actions overturned on appeal in Rome.

    The newly revealed document undermines what the Vatican has said for years – that it never instructed local bishops to withhold evidence of suspected crimes from the police. It could be used as crucial evidence in multi-billion dollar lawsuits against archdioceses in the United States and across the world.

    Vatican dismisses letter
    The Vatican has downplayed the importance of the letter, claiming that it represents an outdated approach to sexual abuse cases and that much has changed since 1997 in the way the Vatican deals with them.  

    “The letter does not in any way suggest that national laws must not be followed. It rightly emphasises (sic.) the importance of always respecting canonical legislation, precisely in order to ensure that guilty parties do not have justified grounds for an appeal and thus producing a result contrary to the one desired,” Vatican spokesman Father Federico Lombardi said in a letter sent to msnbc.com and released on the Vatican Radio web site.  

    “Finally, it must be stated that the letter was written prior to the norms of 2001 which unified responsibility in this field under the jurisdiction of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, a move which has certainly led to clearer guidelines and more effective procedures.” 

    Victim: letter shows cover-up
    But Colm O'Gorman, a survivor of clerical sexual abuse and founder of the Irish charity One-in-Four, said that it’s time the Catholic Church took responsibility for its mishandling of thousands of abuse cases.

    “It’s just not credible to dismiss the letter because it’s 14 years old. It was 1997, not 1597, and nothing has changed since,” O’Gorman told msnbc.com. “This letter is important for a number of reasons: not only because it shows that the Vatican tried to cover-up abuse cases in Ireland, it also proves that Pope Benedict XVI was dishonest in his handling of the scandal.”

    In 2009 a major Irish investigation proved that abuse among clerics in Ireland had been “endemic” for decades. As a result of the landmark investigation, Benedict accepted the resignation of some bishops and ordered an investigation into seminars and dioceses.
    O’Gorman claims that the letter proves that the bishops weren’t to blame – but rather the Vatican.

    “The pope said that the Church of Ireland failed to do their duty, but it turns out it was the Vatican that prevented them from doing the right thing. The Vatican is a state, and the pope is its head. As such, he needs to take responsibility for the church’s failures over the abuses,” said O’Gorman.

    Pope Benedict implicated?
    The newly revealed letter once again calls in to question the role of Pope Benedict in the alleged cover-up of the sexual abuse scandal. 

    Before being elected pope in 2005, Benedict, then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, was in charge of the powerful Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith for 24 years.

    In 2001, he took over control of all investigations into claims of sexual abuse by the clergy. As a conservative theologian, he enforced the procedure set by canon law, which requires bishops to report all case of clerical sexual abuse of minors to the congregation.

    While the Vatican has always maintained that Benedict introduced a more open and efficient system in the way the church deals with abuse cases, critics claim that many priests suspected of sexual abuse were simply moved to different parishes where they continued their abuse – even during his rule.

    Geoffrey Robertson, a human rights lawyer based in London and author of "The Case of the Pope: Vatican Accountability for Human Rights Abuse” believes the letter proves Benedict’s complicity. 

    “This letter reveals a policy that was decided by the Vatican when Ratzinger was head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the office in charge of disciplining priests worldwide. He insisted that canon law was to prevail over civil authorities,” Robertson said in a phone interview Wednesday. “The Vatican line of defense that this was an opinion of an archbishop like Storero, who was out of touch with the times, is nonsense. Ratzinger was head of the congregation since 1981, and all big decisions had to go through him”

    Robertson believes the letter could be extremely damaging in a court of law. “I think that in terms of suing the Vatican for negligence in cases where there is no remedy against the local church, this letter will be useful as evidence of the Vatican’s policy. It might have been directed to Ireland but it applies throughout the world.”
      
    One way or the other, O’Gorman still wants to see some justice for the victims of abuse.

    “They need to come to terms with what they have done,” O’Gorman said. “They need to understand the scale of their negligent behavior on countless lives. It’s disingenuous and immoral.”

  • Royal succession debate shelved til post-nuptials

    By Truus Bos, NBC News Producer 

    LONDON – Prince William and Kate Middleton are still three months from tying the knot, but already British lawmakers are debating the Royal Baby!

    More precisely they are debating whether the first royal child, if she is a girl, can succeed her father William on the throne.

    Under the 309-year-old law which governs royal succession to this day, if William and Kate become the parents of three girls, and then a boy, the boy would leapfrog over the girls and
    become the next in line to the throne.

    This afternoon Labour MP Keith Vaz presented the House of Commons with a Ten Minute Rule Bill calling for the “removal of any distinction between the sexes in determining the succession to the throne.”

    Even before the bill was introduced, Downing Street warned that changing the antiquated law would be a "difficult and complex matter.”

    The reason seems to be that Queen Elizabeth II is still head of state in 15 Commonwealth countries, and the changes would have to be made in all these countries. 

    The Prime Minister's office said discussions have been taking place in these countries, but it could be a lengthy process for any change to be approved.

    "Amending the Act of Succession is a complex and difficult matter that requires careful and thoughtful consideration,” said a spokesman for Prime Minister David Cameron who wished to remain anonymous.

    “Absolute drivel,” said Lord Jeffrey Archer in a televised discussion on the issue last November.

    In 1996 Lord Archer introduced his own bill to make sure that the first-born girls become the monarch. He asked the bill drawing specialists in the Public Bill Office to draft it for him, and "it was a beautiful little bill of one clause! I was allowed to present it to the House. If I was allowed to present it to the House, it must have been all right.”

    "My bill is still there to pick up, and you know how long it would take to get through? A couple of hours! Who's gonna vote against it?" What about the Commonwealth countries making difficulties, Archer said a couple of phone calls should take care of them.

    In Europe, Spain and Monaco are the only other countries who pass over princesses in favor of princes. Denmark was the last European country to make the change in 2009, when 85 percent of the Danish population voted for a referendum which put princesses on an even footing with princes in the succession rules for the Danish Throne.
    Britain has been “ruled” by several strong women – including Queen Elizabeth II since 1953. She is much admired and loved by most of her "subjects,” so it’s doubtful that all but a few curmudgeonly old Lords would still object to allowing a change in the law.

    Williams and Kate would no doubt support a change in the law that would bring equality into their future family. They seem a thoroughly modern couple – they've lived together quite openly before the marriage and announced that they won't surround themselves with a host of servants for a while afterwards.

    This afternoon in the House of Commons the draft bill passed to a second reading by what's called a "voice vote,” which was unanimous, but the House was not full.  It will now be debated on May 13, two weeks after the royal wedding.

  • Stoic Iraqis carry on despite violence

    By Ghazi Balkiz, NBC News Producer
     
    Another attack in Iraq, another deranged suicide bomber takes out dozens of would be policemen.

    The suicide bomber on Tuesday killed at least 52 and wounded many others among a crowd of police recruits looking for work in Saddam Hussein’s hometown of Tikrit. 
     
    The message from the insurgents to the Iraqi people and government was clear: “We are still here. We are still strong. We can reach you when we want; not even your police force can protect you.”
     
    Recruitment centers are very easy targets in Iraq. They are usually buildings surrounded by blast walls and sand bags, but the recruits who are lining up to go inside are not protected, making them sitting ducks.
     
    I just came back from Iraq last Friday. On the ride back home from the airport in London, the taxi driver asked me, “Is it still dangerous there? Is the war still going? Is it safe now?”
     
    I told him Iraq has been at war for a very long time. There was the Iraq-Iran war in the ‘80s, then there was the first Gulf War and then there was the invasion in 2003 and the mayhem that followed it.
     
    Safety in Iraq is a relative term. A few years ago there was war on the streets of almost every major city in Iraq; there were car bombs, suicide bombers, improvised explosive devices, kidnappings, executions, sectarian violence and death squads.
     
    Now the level of violence has dropped significantly, but it has not disappeared.

    People still get killed, suicide bombers still blow themselves up and IEDs still explode.
     
    Last week when I was sitting in the NBC News bureau in Baghdad, a blast killed some people just a few miles from our office. Some of our Iraqi employees looked at each other, shrugged, and carried on with whatever they were doing.
     
    They have gotten used to it. Some of my Iraqi friends say if a few car bombs go off every month, the situation is OK; they figure at least it’s better than what it was a few years ago.
     
    I told the taxi driver that I am not a social behavior analyst, but I think that people adapt to the circumstances that surround them.

    The terror of the past nine years and the violence has numbed many Iraqis, but at the same time, their human nature has helped them carry on with their lives.

  • No vacancy for gay couple at English B&B

    Matt Cardy / Getty Images

    Peter and Hazelmary Bull, owners of the The Chymorvah guesthouse in Marazion near Penzance, Cornwalll pose with a Christian choir outside Bristol County Court on Dec.13, 2010.

    By NBC News’ Peter Jeary

    LONDON – The Cornish coast, in the southwest of England, has long been the haunt of outlaws. Its tradition of smuggling and piracy is part of English folklore, celebrated in the comic operetta Pirates of Penzance.

    On Tuesday, an unlikely couple joined the ranks of Cornwall’s law-breakers: Hotel owners 70-year-old Peter Bull and his wife Hazelmary, 66, who were found guilty of discriminating against a gay couple.

    The Bulls own a hotel in Marazion, a picture-postcard English seaside town a few miles from Penzance. In 2008, Martyn Hall and his civil partner, Steven Preddy, arrived at the hotel to check in.

    To their surprise, they were denied the double room – which they had reserved over the telephone – because of a policy the owners say they have had since buying the bed and breakfast in 1986: Unmarried couples are banned from sharing a bedroom.

    "We accept that the Bible is the holy living word of God and we endeavor to follow it as far as are able. We have a kind of routine we go through with folk. It is never our intention to offend," Hazelmary Bull told the court in her testimony on Tuesday.

    Matt Cardy / Getty Images

    Martyn Hall, right, and his civil partner Steven Preddy, left, outside Bristol County Court as they celebrate winning a landmark case Tuesday against the owners of a Christian hotel who refused them a room.

    Hall and Preddy, however, claimed they were being discriminated against for their sexuality, suing for damages under Britain's 2007 Equality Act.

    In a judgment handed down Tuesday, the Bulls were ordered to pay damages of $2,850 to each of the plaintiffs.
     
    In Tuesday’s ruling, Judge Andrew Rutherford rejected suggestions that the Bulls had been “set-up” by gay rights activists seeking to force the issue.

    Rutherford also described the views of the defendants as "perfectly orthodox Christian beliefs in the sanctity of marriage and the sinfulness of homosexuality."
     
    However, the judge was at pains to say social attitudes in Britain had changed over the past 50 years and that in a parliamentary democracy, it is inevitable there will be laws that cut across deeply-held beliefs.

    "We're really pleased that the judge has confirmed what we already know - that in these circumstances our civil partnership has the same status in law as a marriage between a man and a woman, and that, regardless of each person's religious beliefs, no-one is above the law," the couple said, according to Sky News.

  • Waiting for real change in Tunisia

    Paul Goldman, NBC News

    We arrived at the Tunis Carthage International airport on Saturday moments before the curfew set in. The Tunisian police have been enforcing a tough curfew at nightfall to try to prevent militias from looting shops and government buildings.

    Our luggage was late so we decided to leave it behind and make our way to our hotel in the city center. On our way out of the airport, we saw the first signs of the tension that is being felt everywhere. A big tank was parked at the airport entrance and armed Army men were standing by.

    The streets were mostly deserted and, at every interchange, Army forces stood guard. I noticed about 40 men gathered next to a new building all holding wood sticks and looking very anxious. Our driver Ahmed confirmed that some civilians have decided to work together to guard their assets from looters.

    The armed militias are made up from about 2,000 ex-Presidential guardsmen who are still angry with the protests that unfolded here last week. The Tunisian people, upset with joblessness and flagrant corruption, ousted the ruling President for the past 23 years, Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali.

    These angry militia groups operate only at night, seeking to discredit the people's revolution by causing havoc.

    Now the police and the army are on the hunt for these men. At night while trying to sleep, I could hear choppers on patrol for any signs of people disobeying the curfew.

    This morning, after returning from getting our baggage at the airport, we were stopped by the military. At gun point, we were ordered to sit on the floor, hands by our sides. It was evident these soldiers were very tense. They shouted and made clear they didn't want to hear from us. After 10 minutes that felt like an hour, an army officer showed up, checked our passports and let us go.

    Despite the nation's tense climate, people I spoke with are delighted at this new era of change. They say corruption was so pevasive that it was impossible to live a normal life.

    As we traveled through the city, we took a look at what was left at the house of a relative of the ousted president. The lavish villa overlooking the ocean had been looted and set ablaze. What remains has turned into a living monument to the corrupt way of life that the rich enjoyed, drawing nearby residents to sift through the debris.

    General elections are set to take place in 60 days amid much uncertainty over the nation's future. Tunisians seeking real change are waiting to see what happens.

  • Tunisia: a 'wake-up call' for Arab leaders

    By Charlene Gubash, NBC News Producer

     

    Christophe Ena / AP

    Protesters chant slogans against President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali in Tunis, on Friday.

    CAIRO –  Four months of rioting brought down one of the most authoritarian leaders in the Arab world, Tunisian President Zine al-Abedine Ben Ali, Friday. And many – from Arab analysts to average citizens – believe this may mark a turning point in the Arab World.  

    After two decades of unaccountable leadership, Tunisians suffered from an increasingly unbearable degree of poverty, unemployment, widespread corruption and injustice at the hands of the powerful state security. On Friday they showed the world they’d had enough. But, unfortunately, their plight is a common one shared by the majority of citizens across the Arab world. 

    Many in the region stayed glued to satellite channels Friday watching as Tunisian riot police beat and kicked demonstrators and shot tear gas canisters into crowds. They watched as injured demonstrators were carried away by their colleagues, as the prime minister announced that Ben Ali was no longer in power, and as anchors tried to determine exactly where Ben Ali had fled.

    And many viewers outside Tunisia pondered what lessons their leaders took away.

    “I think it has made governments around the region aware that uprising and revolution can happen in the world. It is a wake-up call for some. Definitely after what happened in Tunisia, things will not be the same as before,” Gamal Abdel Gawad, senior analyst at the al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies in Cairo. “There are many similar countries among non-oil producers, with a lack of democracy and a lack of civil institutions. After Tunisia, perhaps, we will be seeing a different Arab world on the side of the government and people.”

    Gawad pointed out that the coverage of the government’s overthrow was unprecedented. 

    “The last time this happened was in 1985 when the Sudanese overthrew Numeiri and then there was no satellite TV. This is the first upheaval of that sort watched around the clock instantly by everybody in the region, and its impact will be felt.”

    A Cairo University political science professor, Dr. Horeya Megahed, agreed. “This might give a lesson to other governments. They might absorb the problems of the people and respond to them.” 

    However, Hani Sabah, an Egyptian technician, could not imagine a similar reaction in his own country.

    “The oppression the Tunisians faced was so much pressure that it made them explode and do what they did. They suffered from unemployment and high prices,” said Sabah. “But it would be hard for that to happen here with the president and his gang around him…The government’s attitude is: say whatever you want and we will do whatever we want.” 

    Sabah doesn’t anticipate a people's rebellion in Egypt. “Everybody wants to change the system, but the government right now is completely protected … They will shoot at [protesters] with live ammunition. If they are planning to overthrow the government, they will finish them off.” 

    Aly Ibrahim, a Cairo plumber, was glued to the TV on Friday and surfed channels to catch the latest developments. 

    “The Egyptian news broadcast only a fraction of the story for fear people might get the message. Be sure that so many other countries will get the message and will say, ‘These people managed to do that.’ … The message people got is, ‘Enough is enough!’ They see prices rising, problems in society, and nobody is moving a finger.”

  • More than 100 pilgrims die in stampede at Indian festival

    Msnbc.com and news services

    IDUKKI, India -- A stampede of pilgrims returning from one of India's most popular Hindu festivals killed more than 100 people and injured 25 others in southern India Friday night, police said.

    The stampede was set off when a group of pilgrims in a jeep drove into a crowd of worshippers walking along a narrow path ina hilly forest as they returned from offering prayers at the Sabarimala shrine in the state of Kerala, said local police official Sanjay Kumar.

    State officials said the death toll could rise.

    "Sixty-four bodies have been recovered from the accident site. Seventy-five persons have been hospitalised with injuries. Most of them are in three hospitals," Kerala Home Minister Kodiuyeri Balakrishnan told AFP news agency.

    The annual two-month festival attracts millions of worshippers to the remote temple to the Hindu deity Ayyappan. The ceremony Friday marked the end of the festival, and an estimated 150,000 devotees were thought to have taken the narrow path out of the densely forested hills where the stampede took place, the Press Trust of India reported.

    Deadly stampedes are relatively common at temples in India, where large crowds -- sometimes hundreds of thousands of people -- gather in tiny areas with no safety measures or crowd control.

    In March, 63 people were killed when poor villagers scrambled for free food and clothing being given away at a ceremony at a temple in Uttar Pradesh. In 2008, more than 145 people died in a stampede at a remote Hindu temple at the foothills of the Himalayas.

    The Associated Press contributed to this report.

  • 'Still a lot of people buried' in Brazil mudslides as death toll tops 500

    Boulders and other debris are seen Friday in Teresopolis, Brazil.

    Survivors recounted Friday how hillsides crashed down on homes in towns near Rio de Janeiro, as the death toll continued to climb and now tops 500.

    "The number of deaths is going to rise quite a bit. There are still a lot of people buried," Rubens Placido, a fireman in the hard-hit town of Nova Friburgo, was quoted by Reuters as saying. He added that continued rainfall was complicating the search efforts.

    Images shot from a news helicopter showed a hand-written sign saying "Five people still buried" lying on a concrete athletic field partially covered by mud, Reuters correspondent Stuart Grudgings reported.

    In the poor community of Campo Grande on the outskirts of Teresopolis, a wall of water, mud, and rocks the size of cars crashed down from the mountainside, destroying more than 100 houses, Reuters quoted residents as saying.

    "Everything started shaking. It all happened in about five minutes," said Anisio Siqueira da Silva, a 52-year-old whose house remained standing because it was just outside the main path of destruction. "All of my neighbors near here died."

    The area was mostly deserted apart from stray dogs and a few people salvaging belongings and guarding against looters.

    "The chances of finding survivors here are zero," said Leandro Vabo, head of a medical team searching for bodies in Campo Grande.

    Da Silva and others in the village said many of the houses that were swept away had been built too close to the river as the community's population grew in recent years.

    The Associated Press provided this update from correspondent Juliana Barbassa, who is in Teresopolis:

    • Officials said the death toll in four towns north of Rio de Janeiro was still rising and could jump further once rescuers can reach areas cut off by Wednesday's slides. They refused to even guess how many remain missing. Local reports put it in the hundreds.
    • Fernando Perfista, a 31-year-old ranch hand, walked with friends for hours through the night, carrying the body of his 12-year-old boy, the only of his four children he had found. Perfista said uncovered bodies still lay on the ground and the injured were left to suffer because no relief had yet reached them. He said he found his son's body buried in the mud and had to put it in a refrigerator to keep it from dogs while he went out to search without success for his other three children. Friends helped Perfista haul the boy's body to town, where they buried him Friday. Like the scores of other survivors standing outside a morgue in Teresopolis, he was in shock. "My children are in there, in that river bank, under that mud," he said blankly, a hand held to his face.
    • After morning rains caused delays Friday, rescuers resumed efforts, but manpower or resources had yet to reach many in Teresopolis, a mountain city of 163,000 alongside a national park. It holds ornate weekend homes where the wealthy of Rio escape the summer heat to enjoy horseback riding and rock climbing, as well as brick or wood houses built by the poor on denuded land.
    • It is the worst natural disaster to hit Latin America's biggest nation since flooding and slides in Rio de Janeiro and Sao Paulo states killed 785 people in 1967, according to the Brussels-based International Disaster Database, which has records of deadly natural events in Brazil since 1900.
    • Rio state's Civil Defense department said 227 people were killed in Teresopolis and 230 in Nova Friburgo, a 45-mile drive to the west of Teresopolis that draws hikers and campers to mountain trails, waterfalls and dramatic views of lush green slopes. Another 41 died in neighboring Petropolis and 16 in Sumidouro. About 14,000 people were driven from their homes. An additional 37 people died in floods and mudslides since Christmas in other parts of southeastern Brazil.
    • Despite the number of deaths, the relatively low number of injured has surprised officials. Carlos Eduardo Coelho, in charge of the Rio state's health services effort in Teresopolis, said hospitals have ample space. He said that on Thursday, 185 people were treated for injuries in two city hospitals, while 20 people sought treatment in a military field hospital. He said the injuries are not that severe but that he was worried about the health risks to come as even the survivors were "buried in contaminated water" and even people with minor cuts are developing infections.

    Amauri Souza, a 38-year-old who helped Perfista hike his son's body to town, said a few helicopters are reaching remote areas, but "they're only taking down the wounded." He said they were not dropping off food, water or body bags, and he came to town to plead for help.

    Souza said he pulled his wife and 6-month-old daughter to safety when the wall of mud and water hit early Wednesday. But his wife's parents were lost. He heard their screams for help as they were caught up in the mud. Their bodies has yet to be found.

    It's a scene of war and total loss," he said of his area. "I heard my friends screaming for help in the night."

    Now, after the initial disaster, he fears another from hunger, thirst and disease if officials do not act. "The water is rotten, but people are forced to drink it. There is no food. I had meat in my house, but it's all gone bad."

    Flooding and mudslides are common in Brazil when the summer rains come, but this week's slides were among the worst in recent memory. The disasters punish the poor, who often live in rickety shacks perched perilously on steep hillsides with little or no foundations. But even the rich did not escape the damage in Teresopolis, where large homes were washed away.

    More images from the disaster

     

  • Tunisia on the Web

    Msnbc.com staff

    Here’s a roundup of some of the best places to find coverage of the Tunisian crisis.

    Live blogs:

    BBC: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/9361546.stm

    The Guardian: http://www.guardian.co.uk/global/blog/2011/jan/14/tunisia-wikileaks

    Al Arabiya: http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/2011/01/14/133432.html

    Al Jazeera http://english.aljazeera.net/

    Le Monde http://www.lemonde.fr/afrique/article/2011/01/14/suivez-en-direct-la-situation-en-tunisie_1465727_3212.html#ens_id=1245377

    On Twitter

    Guardian’s Paris Correspondent http://twitter.com/#!/achrisafis

    Channel4News Jonathan Rugman http://twitter.com/#!/jrug

    NPR’s Andy Carvan http://twitter.com/#!/search/acarvin

    Al Jazeera correspondent Alan Fisher: http://twitter.com/#!/AlanFisher

    Ann Stewart from CNN: http://twitter.com/#!/annastewartCNN

    Elsewhere:

    http://twitter.com/#!/storyfulpro/tunisia

    http://twitter.com/kev667/bloggers-and-journos

    http://twitter.com/#!/search?q=%23sidibouzid

    http://twitter.com/#!/Anony_Ops

    http://nawaat.org/

    http://twitter.com/nawaat

    Slideshow: State of emergency in Tunisia

    Previous reporting from NBC's Cheryl Gould on Tunisia

    Fighting for press freedom in Tunisia

    One step closer to press freedom in Tunisia

  • Tunisia's embattled president surrenders power

    Christophe Ena / AP

    A demonstrator throws a stone at police during clashes in Tunis, Friday, Jan. 14. Tunisia's president declared a state of emergency and announced that he would fire his government as violent protests escalated Friday, with gunfire echoing in the North African country's usually calm capital and police lobbing tear gas at protesters.

    NBC News, msnbc.com staff and news services

    UPDATE: TUNIS, Tunisia -- Prime Minister Mohammed Ghannouchi said late Friday in a televised address that President Zine El Abidine ï»¿ï»¿Ben Ali has surrendered power and left Tunis.

    Ghannouchi said that he would serve as interim president and will meet representatives of political parties on Saturday to form a government. "Tomorrow will be a decisive day," Ghannouchi told a private Tunisian television station in a telephone interview, Reuters reported. 

    Al Arabiya said a six-member leadership council would be formed to rule the country until elections. The council will be led by the head of Parliament and will include the defense minister.

    Ben Ali had reportedly fled to Malta and was traveling under Libyan protection, Reuters reported. His exact whereabouts were unclear

    Video: Ben Ali steps down amid protests

    French President Nicolas Sarkozy has refused to give Ben Ali permission to enter France, French media reported, citing government sources.  Some members of his family have arrived in the country, the newspaper Le Monde reported. France controlled Tunisia as a protectorate until 1956.

    Later, Al Jazeera television reported Ben Ali was flying to the Gulf.

    The shakeup was certain to have repercussions in the Arab world and beyond — as a sign that massive public outrage could bring down a leader as entrenched and powerful as Ben Ali.

    He had tried vainly to hold onto power amid riots, declaring a state of emergency, dissolving the government and promising new legislative elections within six months. A day earlier, he slashed prices on key foods such as sugar, bread and milk.

    In other developments, Ben Ali's son-in-law, Sakher Materi, a prominent businessman, was in Dubai despite TV reports that he was under arrest in Tunis, an aide told Reuters.

    "He has been in Dubai since midday today," the aide, who did not want to be named, told Reuters after he said he telephoned Materi to check his whereabouts.

    Tunisia's private Nessma television station reported that Materi had been arrested along with several relatives.

    Materi's wealth and business interests have been the focus of suspicion and anger from some Ben Ali opponents, who have accused the former president of nepotism.

    President Barack Obama condemned the violence against protesters. He called on the Tunisian government to respect human rights and hold free and fair elections in the future.

    Slideshow: State of emergency in Tunisia

    -----------------------------------------------------

    Gunfire in the capital
    Earlier, gunfire was heard in the center of the Tunisian capital, as well as the popping of tear gas pistols as police fired on protesters. Police have repeatedly fired on crowds during nearly a month of riots.

    Tunisia's official news agency said that Ben Ali had declared a state of emergency as riots escalated in his North African nation.

    The government also imposed an overnight curfew and banned gatherings of more than three people state television reported. "Arms will be used" if Tunisians refuse to heed the orders, the state media reports said.

    Ben Ali announced earlier in the day that he would dismiss his government and call new legislative elections after thousands of protesters marched through the capital to demand his ouster.

    Protesters mobbed the capital of Tunis on Friday, fueled by pent-up anger at high unemployment and at a leadership many see as controlling and corrupt. Marching through the city, they demanded Ben Ali's resignation and some even climbed onto the roof of the Interior Ministry — a symbol of his repressive regime, which has been criticized as having enriched Ben Ali's family.

    Many shouted "Ben Ali, out!" and "Ben Ali, assassin!" Another poster read "We won't forget," a reference to the rioters killed, many by police bullets.

    Ben Ali promised that the early elections would take place within six months, the official TAP news agency reported. He made no reference, however, to any resignation of his own.

    Helmeted police were seen kicking and clubbing unarmed protesters — one of whom cowered on the ground, covering his face. A few youths were spotted throwing stones at police.

    Protesters shout slogans during a protest against Tunisian President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali , in Tunis, Tunisia, on Friday.

    'The people rose up'
    The demonstrators were of all ages and from all walks of life.

    "A month ago, we didn't believe this uprising was possible," said Beya Mannai, a geology professor at the University of Tunis. "But the people rose up."

    The new unrest came just a day after Ben Ali tried to quell the uproar by going on television to promise lower food prices and new freedoms for Tunisians.


     

    Ben Ali, 74, had maintained an iron grip on Tunisia since grabbing power in 1987 in a bloodless coup, repressing any challenges. He had locked up many opposition figures, clamped down on dissent and kept tight control over the media but had not been able to resolve the country's rising unemployment, officially at nearly 14 percent, but higher for educated youths.

    The unrest began after an educated but jobless 26-year-old committed suicide in mid-December when police confiscated the fruits and vegetables he was selling without a permit. His desperate act hit a nerve, sparked copycat suicides and focused generalized anger against the regime into a widespread, outright revolt.

    The official death toll in the riots is 23, but opposition leaders put the figure at three times that, and medical workers on Friday reported another 13 new deaths and over 50 injuries from late Thursday alone. Police have repeatedly fired on crowds with bullets.
    U.S. diplomatic cables released by WikiLeaks have calledTunisia a "police state" and described the corruption there, and social networks like Facebook have helped spread the comments. Many ordinary Tunisians who have complained for years felt vindicated to see the U.S. diplomatic cables.

    Fethi Belaid / AFP - Getty Images

    Tunisian demonstors gather in front of the interior ministry in Tunis demanding President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali to resign on Friday. Thousands of protesters demanded President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali resign in marches across the country on January 14, emboldened by his dramatic pledge to step down in 2014 in a bid to quell weeks of unrest. "No to Ben Ali, the uprising continues," hundreds shouted in a march down the main boulevard in central Tunis while thousands more took to the streets in other towns shouting "Ben Ali Out!".

    Foundations 'sinking into the sand'
    In a speech on Thursday, U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton warned countries across the Middle East to shake up corrupt institutions and reinvigorate stagnant political systems or risk losing the future to Islamic militants.

    Wrapping up a four-nation tour of U.S. allies in the Persian Gulf with unusually blunt remarks to a regional development conference in the Qatari capital of Doha, Clinton said economic and political space must be opened up for the Arab world's exploding youth population, women and minorities.

    Without that, respect for human rights, improved business climates and an end to pervasive corruption, she said young people and others will increasingly turn to radicalism and violence that will bleed outside the region, threatening not only Middle Eastern stability and security but the rest of the world.

    "In too many places, in too many ways, the region's foundations are sinking into the sand," she told officials at the Forum for the Future conference. "The new and dynamic Middle East ... needs firmer ground if it is to take root and grow everywhere."

    Clinton made her comments after visiting the United Arab Emirates, Oman, Yemen and Qatar. During her trip, civil unrest continued unabated in Tunisia and Algeria, Egypt remained tense after disputed elections and a political crisis hit Lebanon, underscoring what Clinton said where deep concerns about trends in the Middle East.

    "While some countries have made great strides in governance, in many others, people have grown tired of corrupt institutions and a stagnant political order," she said. She appealed for leaders to heed calls to rein in rampant graft and offer all of their people a better way of life.

    "Those who cling to the status quo may be able to hold back the full impact of their countries' problems for a little while, but not forever," Clinton said. "If leaders don't offer a positive vision and give young people meaningful ways to contribute, others will fill the vacuum."

    "Extremist elements, terrorist groups and others who would prey on desperation and poverty are already out there appealing for allegiance and competing for influence," she said. "This is a critical moment and this is a test of leadership for all of us."

    WikiLeaks: 'Chorus of complaints is rising'
    U.S. diplomatic cables released by WikiLeakshave described the corruption in Tunisia, and social networks like Facebook have helped spread the comments. Many ordinary Tunisians who have complained of corruption for years felt vindicated to see the U.S. cables.

    Many Tunisians respect Ben Ali, but many also have grievances with him and members of his family, some of whom have prominent roles in business and public life.

    The U.S. ambassador to Tunisia at the time, Robert Godec, wrote about the president in a July 2009 cable published by the WikiLeaks website: "He and his regime have lost touch with the Tunisian people."

    "Corruption in the inner circle is growing. Even average Tunisians are now keenly aware of it, and the chorus of complaints is rising," the cable said.

    Tunisia's style of government, say some analysts, sits uneasily with the growing sophistication of its people. Tunisia has a large middle class, people are well-educated, and many have close ties to Europe.

    "In Tunisia, the educated middle class is exasperated. Hence the involvement of lawyers and academics in the protests," said Benjamin Stora, a leading French historian of the Maghreb region that includes Tunisia. "This (the wave of unrest) looks like a real
    social movement to try to unlock the system."

    And social media has played an impotant role: For example, Facebook users make up 18.6 percent of the population, according to Internet marketing consultancy socialbakers, a higher penetration than in Germany.

    "The whole story would not have been the same without Facebook and Twitter and other new media," said Ahmed Mansoor, a UAE-based rights activist and blogger. "It played a vital role in bringing what's going on there [in Tunisia] to the world."

    'Clearly something going on'
    The unprecedented riots that have shaken Tunisia have been closely followed on regional satellite television channels and the Internet across the Middle East where high unemployment, bulging young populations, sky-rocketing inflation and a widening gap between rich and poor are increasingly of concern.

    "There is a danger in ... getting a bit too comfortable with the 'Arab state will muddle through' argument," said Stephen Cook of the U.S. Council on Foreign Relations in a blog this week. "It may not be the last days of Ben Ali or (Egypt's President Hosni) Mubarak or any other Middle Eastern strongman.

    "But there is clearly something going on in the region."

    "This could happen anywhere," said Imane, a restaurant owner in Egypt who did not want to give her full name. "The satellite and Internet images we can see nowadays mean people who would normally be subdued can now see others getting what they want."
    While in recent decades democracy has supplanted despotism in regions once plagued by dictators, governments in the Arab world are almost uniformly autocratic and heavily policed.

    Yet some think the concessions wrung from Ben Ali, as well as efforts in Algeria to appease anger over price increases, have punctured the fear factor that has long kept discontent in check across the region.

    "Perhaps all the Arab governments are monitoring with eyes wide open what is happening in Tunisia and Algeria," columnist Abdelrahman al-Rashed wrote in Asharq al-Awsat newspaper.

    "Much of what prevents protest and civil disobedience is simply the psychological barrier," he said. "Tunisia's president has promised all he can to stop the trouble and Algeria reversed price decisions, but the psychological barrier is broken."

    Travel alerts
    In Tunisia, the demonstrations started in mid-December after an educated but jobless 26-year-old committed suicide when police confiscated the fruits and vegetables he was selling without a permit.

    The riots this week reached Tunis, the capital of this North African tourist haven on the Mediterranean.
    The unrest was taking a heavy toll on the key tourism industry there, which is known for its wide sandy beaches, desert landscape, ancient ruins and bustling bazaars.

    British tour operator Thomas Cook said it was asking its roughly 3,800 British, Irish, and German customers in Tunisia to leave the country, while some 200 Dutch tourists were repatriated Thursday night via a chartered flight.

    U.S. and European governments have issued a series of travel alerts warning citizens away from nonessential travel to Tunisia.
    The unrest was having diplomatic consequences as well.

    Tunisia's ambassador to the U.N. cultural and educational agency resigned amid the deadly riots. Mezri Haddad, ambassador to Paris-based UNESCO, said on France's BFM television Friday, "I am resigning today."

    He said he is resigning because he doesn't want to contribute to something that "is the opposite of my convictions and my conscience."

  • 'Queensland spirit' prevails amid the floods

    BRISBANE, Australia – An elderly man stood beside the muddy water inundating his neighborhood, the tops of road signs the only evidence that 24 hours earlier the area had been a busy junction in Brisbane's Fairfield neighborhood. 

    I expected, despair, anger even.

    Simon Balmer / NBC News

    Kayakers take to the flooded streets of Milton, a suburb of Brisbane, Australia.

    Instead there was a smile: "I'm King Canute," he said, referring to the 11th century Viking king who legend said could command the tides. "There's no turning this back."

    A little further along the road I met Catherine Dalton. She was standing beside her water-logged house, a frustrated look on her face. On seeing me, she brightened, and I soon realized why.

    "Gotta save the barbie," she announced, recruiting me to help carry her substantial barbecue to a friend's house on higher ground across the street.

    There's no doubting the severity of the floods in Australia's third largest city, even though they didn't quite peak Thursday as high as had been feared.

    About 30 of Brisbane's suburbs have been inundated, affecting an estimated 35,000 homes, many of which will never be habitable again, even after the water recedes.

    Queensland's Premier Anna Bligh has called it the worst natural disaster in the history of the state, possibly in Australian history.

    Floods have been sweeping across Queensland since early December. The latest phase of the flooding hit the southeast part of the state and killed at least 14 people, with dozens still missing. The death toll is expected to rise.

    Yet in spite of all this, there is tremendous resolve – and humor, much of it of the darker ilk – amid tragedy.

    Simon Balmer / NBC News

    Residents look at the flooded streets of Milton, a suburb of Brisbane.

    ‘Queensland spirit’
    Australia's Prime Minister Julia Gillard called it the "Queensland spirit" when I met her Wednesday. I didn't take that too seriously at the time, but after two days traveling around the state's water-logged capital, I can see what she was getting at.

    On one street corner a dive shop put out fresh signs: "Learn to dive now!" it invited passing motorists.

    While in another district where several factories and a stadium were under water, a small group bemoaned that the floods represented an attack on the Australian way of life.

    "It's taken out the footy stadium and the brewery. How can we recover from this?" one man asked me. Just down the cordoned off street was one of the city's main sports stadiums, across the road from the Castlemaine Brewery, purveyor of “XXXX,” one of Brisbane's most famous beers.

    Across the city, suburban roads have become rivers. On Thursday the new waterways were plied by kayaks, small boats, as well as rescue teams – lifeguards, more used to patrolling the beach – looking for those stranded in their homes.

    Most people did evacuate, as advised, before the peak flood hit, but some did stay. We witnessed a rescue team bringing to dry ground a young woman and her boyfriend, who had thought they could sit out the flood. A silly decision really, but nobody seemed to hold it against them.

    Ian Williams / NBC News

    Rescue workers prepare to take to the flooded streets of Milton, a suburb of Brisbane.

    "No power, no phone – and then the beer ran out. It was getting pretty boring," the woman told me.

    It will take a long time for Brisbane – and Queensland – to recover, but the prime minister is right. There is spirit here. They will bounce back. 

  • Assange case: Has feminism gone too far?

    AFP - Getty Images file

    Sweden is seeking Julian Assange's extradition from Britain.

    By F. Brinley Bruton, msnbc.com

    LONDON - Polemical filmmaker Michael Moore seems in no doubt that dark forces are behind the rape and sexual molestation accusations leveled against WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange in Sweden.

    “Governments and corporations go after individuals … they go after people with this kind of lie and smear,” Moore told MSNBC’s Countdown with Keith Olbermann. “This is all a bunch of hooey as far as I’m concerned.”

    But while many WikiLeaks supporters contend that powerful international interests are misusing Sweden’s sterling feminist credentials to stifle the man at the helm of the organization, the debate in the country has taken a dramatically different direction.

    Many in Sweden reject claims that Assange, who appeared in a London court Tuesday, is the victim of a U.S.-led conspiracy. Instead, the country has been gripped by a very public and often explicit discussion about intimate behavior and relationships. The case has even made some question whether feminism has been taken too far in this supposed bastion of gender equality.

    Assange is wanted in Sweden for questioning after two women accused him of rape, sexual molestation and unlawful coercion. Stockholm is seeking his extradition from Britain although he has not been charged with any crime.

    Feminism is a mainstream concept in Sweden and the country has among the toughest sex crime laws in the world. In fact, lawyers have been known to joke that a man must get written permission before having sex.

    “WikiLeaks has vocal supporters (in Sweden), who by the way I am one,” says prominent feminist and journalist Johanna Koljonen, whose blog posts helped kick-off a fervent discussion when she revealed in intimate detail an experience that echoed the allegations against Assange.

    But her support for the organization has nothing to do with whether Assange is guilty or not under Swedish law, she added. However, his case has reminded her of an encounter that left her uncomfortable.

    “I woke up in a sexual situation with a partner with whom I has just a few hours earlier had consensual sex on the condition that we use a condom,” she wrote.

    “It is often very clear what a rape is and what has happened, but even then we know it’s difficult for the parties to get a fair hearing in court,” Koljonen added. “Then there are the situations in which acts have been performed which may or may not be illegal, depending on the parties’ negotiation of consent. This principle makes legal situations complicated, but it is of vital importance: we should not and cannot legislate acceptable sexual practice.”

    Koljonen’s blog post fed a growing discussion and soon Prata om det (#prataomdet on Twitter), or “Talk about It”, was born. The website has received more than 226,000 page views with the average user staying for seven minutes.

    'Honest conversation'
    The site encourages users to discuss negative sexual experiences and reveal times when “boundaries were violated.”

    “Initiating an honest conversation about sex and consent is scary,” the site says. “Reactions can be cold or even hostile towards those who try. Because of this, many people hold their tongue and put a lid on their thoughts – but that doesn’t make the thoughts go away.”

    In a post entitled “I’m a nice guy,” one male user posted that despite his best efforts he has not always behaved in a way he is proud of.

    “I have the notion that I have a very enlightened and equal view on sex,” he wrote. “Sadly, my feelings and practical application isn’t as evolved and that hurts both myself and others close to me.”

    In Sweden, the word "tjatsex" - defined by Koljonen as "nagging sex ... sex that you talked someone into having even when they didn’t feel like it" - has even entered the mainsteam.

    Journalist Sonja Schwarzenberger, who has been involved with the website since the beginning, says it is a forum for women and men to safely discuss negative sexual experiences.

    “Our idea was, how not to make it black and white is to say, 'here it is, this is my experience.'”

    Fair trials difficult?
    For weeks, the debate has dominated the airwaves and newspapers in Sweden.

    But while many view the ability to discuss the ambiguous intimate issues as a positive thing, the gray area often referred to and the country’s relatively broad definition of rape alarms others.

    Pelle Billing, a M.D. who lectures and writes on gender and men's issues, worries that Sweden’s rape and domestic violence laws make it difficult for men to get a fair trial.

    He cites a quote by the lawyer for Assange’s accusers, who went to the police for advice before deciding to file charges.

    “Women who are assaulted don't always define it as that,” said lawyer Claes Borgstrom, who is the Swedish Social Democratic Party’s spokesman on gender equality. “It's a big problem in our society and it can be difficult to assess what has happened if you are not a lawyer."

    “So how is man supposed to know what the boundaries are if the women don’t know?” Billing asks. According to him, feminism in Sweden has stopped being about equal rights and has begun to infringe on men’s rights.

    So Billing spends little time worrying whether the case against Assange is the result of U.S. pressure on Sweden and instead focuses on whether Swedish courts uphold the presumption of innocence for men accused of rape and domestic violence.

    Billing was excoriated in public for discussing his beliefs and the Assange case on a leading current affairs program.

    'Without shame'
    Even some Swedes who call themselves feminists concede that sexual violence and rape laws are sometimes applied unfairly.

    “It is important in this Julian Assange case to understand the situation,” says Per Samuelson, a defense lawyer who focuses on defending men accused of rape. “Everyone (around the world) is shouting that Julian Assange is innocent (but) people in Sweden think otherwise because they tend to believe the women in over 90 percent of the cases.”

    Comments like these no doubt trouble Assange and his defense team. But they are in stark contrast to the views espoused by vocal WikiLeaks supporters such as prominent Canadian feminist Naomi Klein.

    “Rape is being used in the Assange prosecution in the same way that women's freedom was used to invade Afghanistan. Wake up!" she said of the case against him.

    But for many in Sweden, the Assange case has crystallized important issues around personal boundaries, sexuality and the law.

    As journalist Koljonen says: “How can judges and juries and the media be expected to speak honestly and think coolly about things we can’t even say to ourselves without shame?”

  • Coptic Christians just want to be treated 'like Egyptians'

    Mohamed Muslemany / NBC News

    Parishoners at Christmas Eve mass in the Coptic Cathedral in Abassiya, Cairo on Jan. 6.

    By Charlene Gubash, NBC News Producer
    CAIRO – Christmas Eve mass for Coptic Christians in Egypt is usually a joyous celebration. Worshippers typically throng churches, smoky with incense, to attend services chanted in Coptic and Arabic verse by ornately dressed clergy.   

    But this year’s midnight service at Cairo’s Coptic Cathedral was different: Worshippers had to cross rows of riot police and pass through five metal detectors, opening purses and flashing IDs each time, before being allowed to enter.
     
    The tightened security came after a deadly terrorist attack against Egypt’s Christian minority; last week, a suicide bomber killed 21 Copts and injured nearly 100 more at New Year’s Eve mass in the port city of Alexandria.   
     
    Most parishioners donned black this Christmas, mourning the victims of the attack, suspected to have been the work of Islamist militants, and expressed more anger than joy. 

    “How do I feel? I am sad, I am depressed,” exclaimed Faizah Farah, a secretary in a government ministry who attended Christmas Eve mass in Cairo. “I am wearing black on Christmas! In order to enter my heavenly father’s home, I must be searched! If there had been security like this [before], nobody would have died last week.” 

    But after more discussion, it became clear that the shocking depth of anger, alienation and vulnerability shared by Farah and other Copts was not just a reaction to the most recent attack, but the culmination of a lifetime of real or perceived discrimination felt by the Coptic minority, which makes up 10 percent of Egypt’s 80 million people.   


     

    “This was originally our country, a Coptic country until the Muslims came and took it over,” said Farah. “Why are we being discriminated against now? We don’t get the positions we want because we are Christians. They see a Christian name on the application and they back away.”  
     
    ‘We take care of each other’
    Maria, a 30-year-old architect who was also at the mass, refused to give her last name out concern for her own security. But she said that for Copts, it is almost impossible to get good government jobs, especially in universities. Her first job was with a Christian-only company, but she is now technical manager for a Muslim-owned construction firm. She said she got the job after testing for the position and became the first Christian engineer hired to join a team of 19 Muslims. Since she started her job, Maria said, she has become friends with many of her Muslim colleagues, whom she describes as well-educated and open-minded. 

    Mohamed Muslemany / NBC News

    Pope Shenouda III celebrates Christmas Eve midnight mass at the Coptic Cathedral in Abassiya Cairo, Egypt on Jan.6.

    Still, Maria says she and her husband have chosen to surround themselves with Christians as much as possible because it gives her a sense of safety. They live in a predominantly Christian neighborhood in Cairo, and their daughter, Miriam, 2, attends a Christian daycare. Her husband, Isaac, owns a computer company and says he hires only Christians. 

    “We take care of each other. When I am in a Christian circle, it is safer for me. It is a feeling of security, like the feeling I get from being in church rather than on the street,” Maria said. She said she knows many Copts who feel the same way.
     
    Even in grade school, Copts see religious discrimination.

    Farah’s 6-year-old daughter, Miriam, first attended a school where only one teacher out of 45 was Christian. Farah yanked Miriam out of the school after teachers forced her to remove her cross-shaped pendant while her Muslim classmates where allowed to wear veils and jewelry bearing Islamic inscriptions.

    Mohamed Muslemany / NBC News

    Faiza Farah celebrates Christmas Eve mass at the Coptic Cathedral in Abassiya Cairo on Jan.6.

    Christian children were obliged to learn Arabic by reciting the Quran and were penalized if they refused to repeat phrases that contradicted their religious beliefs. Miriam now attends a private Christian school where the principal insists “there is no difference between Muslim and Christian students.”   
     
    Fear restricts movements
    Many Copts share a broad sense of fear and vulnerability in Egypt’s increasingly conservative Muslim society. Farah’s oldest daughter attends university in Helwan, south of Cairo, but she insists on driving her to and from school out of fear she could be kidnapped. Farah admitted that she does not know any Christian girls who have been kidnapped, but she insists it does happen and that victims are first raped and then forced to convert to Islam. 

    “My children feel like they are being discriminated against. I want to leave this country for anywhere that we will be safe and not suffer discrimination! I have three daughters to protect.”
     
    Farah said she ventures from the protection of her home as little as possible. “I leave the house only to take my daughters to school. Because I am not veiled, they know I am Christian. When I go out, I have been spat at. When I drive and people see the image of the cross on my bumper, they try to crowd me. Whenever I take the bus, I am obliged to listen to the radio playing Quran, even if I don’t want to.” 

    The woman sitting next to Farah in the church pew chimed in. “It is our country, but we feel that we are strangers here!”
     
    Maria also grew angry as she cited instances of religious discrimination. “Sometimes you hear a car or store playing a recording of [an Islamic] religious sermon that trashes Christians. During Ramadan, [Muslim] men see me without a veil and exclaim, ‘God, forgive us!’ as if they wish they hadn’t seen me. And the Quran calls us ‘kafir’ (infidels).”

    ‘I need to be treated as an Egyptian’
    Both women hope that Egyptian society becomes more secular.

    Farah believes the government must first amend the law that largely prevents Christians from building new churches, remove religious affiliation from identification cards, and secularize education.

    But Maria insisted, “I don’t need protection from the government. I need to be treated equally. I need to be treated as an Egyptian.”

Jump to January 2011 archive page: 1 2