In Beijing, residents resist the wrecker's ball


Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

BEIJING — At first, it looked like an earthquake had struck Laogucheng.

Piles of rubble from collapsed buildings, exposed rebar, shattered tiles and bricks, debris everywhere in Beijing’s far western district of Shijingshan.

But this was no quake zone.

Scrawled on the remaining walls was the Chinese character for demolish, “cai.” Government slogans printed in neat red characters ran along half-standing buildings: “The earlier you tear down your home, the sooner you will benefit” or “Communist Party members should take the lead to demolish first.”

Photo by Adrienne Mong/NBC News

The Chinese character for demolish, "cai," is scrawled on the remains of buildings throughout Laogucheng.

Laogucheng is now better known as a demolition area only a handful of miles from Chang’an Jie, or the Avenue of Perpetual Peace, which cuts through the heart of Beijing.

The majority of the community’s homes and most of its shops have been knocked down since last summer to make way for a new development.

“This place had bad infrastructure, a very dense population and a lot of illegal buildings,” said Li Guo Chen, Chief Demolition Director of the Shijingshan District Government. “Security was also a big problem. Therefore, the district government considers it a very important project to rebuild and improve the whole area.”

The plan is to construct high-rise apartment buildings – some of which will be allocated to the current residents – with commercial and retail space for lease.

“About 70 percent of the residents have moved out,” continued Li. “Which proves our plan is recognized by the community.”

Not so fast.


Resisting resettlement
Not with holdouts like Liang Shenli, a 61-year-old retired businessman who lives in Laogucheng with his wife and son.

“I’m not leaving, because they are unwilling to negotiate the terms on a fair basis,” said Liang, referring to local officials. Like many of his neighbours, the homeowner said the compensation package he’s been offered is based on an inaccurate calculation of the land he says he owns. The original terms don’t include the garden extension he built years ago and shortchanges him on the market value of the property.

Moreover, Liang and others say they’ve come under pressure to accept the initial terms and to move as quickly as possible. “Look at this neighbourhood,” he said, his arm sweeping across two city blocks’ equivalent of rubble. “The roads are unpassable. No one comes to pick up the garbage. They might not have applied pressure, but they’re making it uncomfortable for us to continue living here.”

Some residents also mentioned rocks thrown at the windows of their homes “It is a little scary,” said Liang. “You don’t feel safe.”

“It’s not true,” said Li, the Shijingshan official interviewed by NBC News. Without addressing the question about interrupted power, he said the main road was blocked, which prevented trucks from entering the area to remove garbage and debris.

Li also said no one would be forced to move, but he maintained confidence that the stragglers would soon come around. “Some may not agree and need time to understand,” he said. “We believe with our careful and patient work, they will eventually agree.”

Across Beijing, just north of the Forbidden City, yet another neighbourhood risks being demolished, but this one has attracted widespread attention because of its historic value.

Save the hutongs
Old Beijing, as it’s commonly known, encompasses dozens of hutongs, or alleyways, that date back to the Yuan Dynasty more than 700 years ago. It’s also home to the Drum and Bell Towers, two imposing but elegant edifices that loom over the one-story buildings in the area. Built in 1272, they were used to tell time in the ancient capital during China’s final three dynasties (Yuan, Ming, Qing).

“It’s one of the few areas that’s still left in Old Beijing with great cultural and historical value,” says He Shuzhong, a conservationist who founded the Beijing Cultural Heritage Protection Centre. “Their cultural value is as high as the Forbidden City.”

Photo by Adrienne Mong/NBC News

Traditional hutongs, which could be razed, line the streets of Old Beijing below the Drum and Bell Towers.

The area also has great commercial value.

Local newspapers have reported plans to raze many of the hutongs surrounding the towers to make way for a new development. The $73 million facelift would include a massive underground complex composed of parking lots, shops and a museum. Above ground, a public square would replace the hutongs and ancient courtyard homes.

“Of course, there are many problems there, like hygiene, the dense population, unreasonable transport system, bad tourism routes [that cut through the hutongs] and poor commercial facilities,” said He. “But these problems should be solved through management and gradual planning” and, especially, discussion with the local residents.

But none of the people we interviewed in hutongs around the Bell Tower had been informed of any municipal re-development plans. What little they knew, several of them said, came from the newspaper reports.

“We haven’t been told anything by anyone,” said one woman who was washing clothes in a plastic tub on the sidewalk (one of the charms of the neighborhood is that life in the hutong is lived out in the hutong). “Everyone is talking about it, but nobody knows the exact date for the demolition.”

The absence of information has only served to create anxiety and suspicion among the hutong dwellers – many whose families have lived here for several generations. Although some said they would consider moving given fair compensation for their property, many still refuse to consider the idea on principle.

Take 48-year-old Liu Hongqian, who was smoking a cigarette outside the courtyard he’s lived in all his life.

“I definitely won’t move if they want us out as far as the Sixth Ring Road,” he said, referring to one of the suburbs farthest out of central Beijing. “If you live that far, you have to buy a car, how much gas do you have to use every day? We make so little money.”

Liu also dismissed the notion of having a modern new apartment with amenities. “I feel more comfortable here even if I only have a 100-square-foot room.”

Another resident, who would only give his surname, put it succinctly. “City dwellers are being moved out to the countryside while migrant workers from the countryside are moving into the city,” said Mr. Sha, referring to the mass migration of people from rural areas looking for jobs in urban centers.

But, overwhelmingly, there was the sense of distrust – that whatever the government or developers promised, there was no guarantee of being treated fairly.

The great land grab
After all, land grabs have become widespread across China for years now, stoked by soaring property prices, especially in growing urban centers. Developers, often backed by local authorities, seize or buy old homes at extremely low prices for redevelopment and, in the process, enrich municipal governments or local officials. (See this nifty Explainer.)

Occupants refusing to resettle have resorted to a wide variety of forms of resistance. One of the more creative tactics was deployed — literally — by a 56-year-old farmer living on the outskirts of Wuhan city in Hubei Province.

After chasing off an earlier eviction attempt with the help of rockets, Yang Youde built a cannon out of a wheelbarrow and pipes, which uses ammunition made from fireworks, to wage war with a group of 100-something men who tried to toss him off his farmland late last month.

A local government official was quoted in the China Daily as saying authorities have offered Yang just over $19,000 for his fields, but the farmer reckons it’s worth at least five times as much. Yang said he’s been forced to protect himself because demolition workers hired by the developer had threatened to use force on him after compensation negotiations with the local authorities had faltered in March.

Discuss this post

We had the honor of visiting Beijing in September, 2008 for the Paralympics. We stayed in 'Old Beijing' near the Bell Tower because we wanted to experience hutong life. It was incredible and really gave us a glimpse of how people lived. We loved every minute of it. Seeing family members hanging out in the hutongs playing games, washing, cooking, reading, playing. It would be a travesty if the Chinese government were to demolish this way of life. Each ring of the city that moved out of the center became more modern and westernized and to us, sterile. I hope the people there are able to fight for their right to live how they lived for many years. Even if it was 'poor' by western standards, they seemed very happy and content.

  • 1 vote
Reply#1 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 10:03 AM EDT

I agree with this statement so much that I can't even begin to vocalize it.

  • 1 vote
#1.1 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 10:36 AM EDT

Fight for their right? This is China we're talking about.

  • 1 vote
#1.2 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 11:22 AM EDT
Reply

I have to admit that it's so very disheartening to hear that policies once again have overturned culture and history. We were on our honeymoon in Beijing for the Olympics in 2008 and one of the beautiful places we visited was to the hutong areas where the Bell Drum Towers were situated. To see the culture so ever present in a modern day city was breathtaking. To have a mix of the old and new ways is what defines this city. And to lose it to concrete is a sham.

    Reply#2 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 10:12 AM EDT

    They can protest all they want. The glorious Communist regime will prevail. Resist and you will diaappear. I detest China along with North Korea.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#3 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 10:31 AM EDT

    Sounds defeatist Charles. Power is always in numbers. Ghandi proved it. The will of a country can be delayed but change is inevitable. ( I read this in a fortune cookie)

      #3.1 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 8:05 PM EDT

      Charles, aka Dr Strangelove/ Capt Ahab,

      Guess you have found a new Whale to chase after the demise of the USSR.

      I suggest you go to night school and learn about Chinas 5000 year history

        #3.2 - Fri Aug 13, 2010 7:49 PM EDT
        Reply

        I also have had the pleasure and honor of spending time in the hutongs of old Beijing. I had many opportunities to visit with residents and listen to them as they talked about the family history and ownership of the courtyard home they lived in. Many families had 400/500 years of living in the same building. This is much of the basis for the closeness of the Chinese families. There are certainly areas of cities of the world that should be torn down and replaced with clean modern living facilities, such as the flavias of Rio De Janerio, but the hutongs of old Beijing is not one of them. They are China and if the government destroys the hutongs, they are destroying China.

        • 1 vote
        Reply#4 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 10:50 AM EDT

        I was in Beijing in 2008 for the Paralympics. I am happy to say we stayed in the Hutong (next to the Bell Tower) for the two and a half weeks we were in Beijing. I wouldn't have wanted to stay anywhere else after experiencing life in the Hutong. The people and the culture I experienced while there, was so very enlightening. The people are so very happy and friendly. It was great to see how families could live together with so little and such a simple way of life. They even used what little space they had to grow vegetables and flowers and hang there laundry. I still to this day think back to that time, and how much I enjoyed it. Even thou our cultures and language are so different, I felt a bond with these people. I can only hope that the Chinese people and the rest of the world can put pressure on the Chinese govt. to save this last part of the original Beijing culture. Let these people live the way they have for centuries without modern apartments and high rises. I only wish there was some way I could help these people save their Hutong !

        • 1 vote
        Reply#5 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 11:06 AM EDT

        Yeah, well whatever your opinions are on this subect this is China.

        The choices are a wrecking ball or tanks. Both very effective.

          Reply#6 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 11:21 AM EDT

          I have one thing to say about China and prosperity: careful what you wish for... you might get it.

            Reply#7 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 11:48 AM EDT

            I too, hope the wishes of the people in the district prevail and compromise can be reached between developers, officials and the residents, if indeed this type of "renovation" is being considered. It seems from the article, to me that there has not been that much contact with residents of the district about such a plan. Is the subject throughly researched regarding this district before publishing? Also, as is the case in any other country, whether a Communist regime or not, I believe that greed and corruption will prevail. Of course "only for the good of the people".

              Reply#8 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 12:09 PM EDT

              Why Communism? WHY!!!!

              Its a great idea on paper, but in real life, some people are more "fair" than others.

                Reply#9 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 12:16 PM EDT

                Change is always disturbing, but is a reality for all society weither for Communist or Capitalists. Cities that dont change eventually wear out and fall down and die out and while tens of thousands of people may be displaced in this incident, how many more people will now have homes? Older isnt always better and truth is the Chinese people have a higher standard of living today then hundreds of years past. It's wonderful to see history, but the reality is that to make room for the new and progress, you must give up something of the past. Digging in any older city like Mexico City, Beijing and Rome you cant go 1 foot without finding relics of the past. Should these people / governments just give up on their ancient cities and move away and turn them into museums and tourist traps? or let the city do what it was designed to do and that is to grow!

                  Reply#10 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 1:45 PM EDT

                  You obviously have never been there.

                    #10.1 - Sat Jun 19, 2010 1:12 AM EDT
                    Reply

                    The Chinese government should wise up and preserve this place for a tourist attraction. The Europeans were smart enough to do that and have reaped the benefits, and will forever!

                      Reply#11 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 2:18 PM EDT

                      I dought the goverment will destroy the old structures, They will build around them. I have lived here now for more than a year, you see a 500 year old structure and a 60 story building next to it.

                      They believe too much in the past and tradition to actually destroy something so valuable.

                      Chinese people are not stupid, not more evil than many western goverments.

                        #11.1 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 6:46 PM EDT
                        Reply

                        I spent 10 years developing real estate in a joint venture with the government.

                        Nothing ever happens the way we Americans think it should. The game is fraught with corruption, power struggles, and greed. No, the common man doesn't have much of a chance to get anything extra out of his suffering during the redevelopment. Mostly he is lucky to get 75% of the old market value when it was a run-down mess, although after redevelopment, the values might be 10 times that old number.

                        That's just the way it is. Every culture has a price to pay for it's advancement. It might be a war, it might be something else.

                        The central power in China is not apt to change, nor are most of their inbred and unfair systems. Like it is here, poor people have little power.

                          Reply#12 - Fri Jun 18, 2010 2:21 PM EDT

                          From the picture of the buildings, they are definately not those old houses in Hutong unless you have the eyes of Adrienna Mong, the typical American BS artist employed as reporter to bad mouth China.

                          • 1 vote
                          Reply#13 - Tue Jun 22, 2010 12:08 PM EDT
                          You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                          As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.